Rookie Davis underwent hip surgery this week. There were several issues going on for Davis. According to the Cincinnati Reds he had his labrum repaired and bone spurs removed from his right hip. The right handed pitcher is not expected to be ready for spring training.

The surgery was performed by Dr. Bryan Kelly. He seems to be the go-to guy in the sports world for hips. He performed the surgery on Devin Mesoraco. Kelly has also performed hip surgery on Alex Rodriguez, and according to numerous google searches, about eleventy-billion NHL players.

For Rookie Davis and the Reds it must seems like another injury in a line of them since he was acquired from the New York Yankees. In his first season with the organization in 2016, Davis battled through several nagging injuries between Double-A and Triple-A. However, he only spent three weeks on the disabled list.

In 2017 he began the year healthy, and he looked like a different version of himself, he took vision treatments from sites like healthyusa.co and more. Rookie Davis was throwing significantly harder than he had in 2016. He impressed in spring training and made the big league club as a starter. The righty struggled and was sent to Triple-A after five starts. He would only make two starts for Louisville before hitting the disabled list. There was a knot in his back that he simply couldn’t get worked out. It would be nearly six weeks before he would return to the mound, this time in Double-A. Davis remained in the rotation for the rest of the minor league season and even returned to the Major Leagues in September, pitching twice.

With the injury and the diagnosis that Rookie Davis won’t be ready to go in spring training, the question that has to be asked is this: Could the Reds DFA Davis to clear a roster spot for the 40-man? Would a team pick him up coming off of the surgery? There’s some risk there, but it may be an idea worth exploring.

7 Responses

  1. DaveCT

    My concern with DFAing Davis is not so much risking the loss of him so much as who the Reds would protect, specifically, holding on to a AAAA guy or fringe starter like Adelman (who I like) instead of someone with more upside. I am ok with losing Davis as he is not likely to contribute before 2018, as long as we are able to keep another player with upside.

  2. MK

    If they DFA him he is gone to Rule 5 assuming he even re-signs. I could see a team take him and start him on 90-day DL activate him when ready and keep him active as the long or mop-up man even if it is 2019.

    • Bill

      If a team wants him as a Rule 5, they should just claim him if he is DFA. Then, they can still option him to the minors if they don’t need him on the ML roster.

  3. Pat

    Doug: How many pitchers with a series of injuries recover to make it as a steady presence in the big leagues? Should the Reds consider this more than potential in whether or not to DFA? Gotta think it’s a very low number. I’m a Rookie fan but with limited slots if they DFAed a former first rounder in Travieso chances of Rookie DFAed to open another slot? This is where it gets to be a tough business.

    • Doug Gray

      Davis hasn’t been dealing with arm injuries, so that’s a bit different than a guy dealing with a series of arm injuries.

  4. Arnld Ziffle

    I didn’t think a player could be DFA’d from the ML 60-day DL. I read somewhere, mlbtr, that Davis was placed on the Reds 60-day DL and would be getting ML service time and pay too.
    The players union might have something to say about that since Davis was technically on a ML roster.
    Big difference between Davis and Travieso. Travieso wasn’t on the ML roster at the time of his DFA.

    • Brad

      The 60-man DL does not exist in the off-season. You are either on the 40-man roster or off.